Stay or roll over: What should you do with your 401(k) when you leave a job?

When you leave a job where you’ve been contributing to a 401(k) or 403(b), you generally have four options: leave your savings in your former employer’s plan, roll them into your new employer’s plan, roll them into an Individual Retirement Account (IRA), or withdraw the money. I’ll walk through what each option offers, what to watch for, and how to narrow down the choices for your situation.
Option 1: Leave your retirement savings in your former employer’s plan
You may be able to keep your 401(k) or 403(b) with your former employer after you leave. Staying put can make sense if the plan offers investments that fit your needs at reasonable costs. Confirm that the plan allows your account to remain; smaller balances may be subject to mandatory distribution rules.
It’s common to leave your retirement account in place when you change jobs. Vanguard’s How America Saves 2026 reported the following choices among participants in its defined contribution plans who left their employers in 2025:
| What participants did | Percentage |
| Left the money in the plan | 46% |
| Rolled it over | 25% |
| Took a cash lump sum | 28% |
| Used a combination of rollover and cash | 1% |
Note that these figures describe activity during the year participants left their employers, rather than their eventual decisions.
Before deciding to leave your savings where they are, review the investments, fees, and withdrawal rules. Keep your contact information current and save the plan administrator’s details.
If you’ve borrowed from your 401(k) or 403(b), check the plan’s repayment rules before moving your savings. Leaving your job may trigger a requirement to repay the loan in full, and any unpaid balance could become taxable. Because IRAs don’t offer participant loans, rolling your savings into an IRA doesn’t carry the loan over with them.
No More Guesswork — Get Expert Insight Delivered Straight to Your Inbox Every Week
Option 2: Roll your retirement savings into your new employer’s plan
If you’re starting another job, your new employer’s 401(k) or 403(b) may accept a rollover from your old plan. A rollover moves eligible retirement savings between eligible retirement accounts. Moving pretax money into another eligible pretax account generally preserves tax deferral when the rollover rules are followed.
The appeal of a rollover is simplicity: fewer accounts to monitor and one place to manage your workplace retirement savings.
Your new employer’s plan isn’t automatically better just because it’s newer. Before committing to a retirement account rollover, confirm that your new plan accepts the type of savings you want to move, then compare its investment options, total fees, services, and withdrawal rules with your old plan.
Option 3: Roll your 401(k) or 403(b) into an IRA
An IRA is a retirement account you open independently of your employer. Depending on the provider, it may offer a broader investment selection, different services, and a place to consolidate savings from previous jobs.
Before moving your money, consider whether those investments and services meet your needs and what you would pay for them. Compare account fees, investment expenses, and any advisory fees, along with differences in withdrawal rules and creditor protections.
IRA rollovers are sometimes recommended by financial advisors who stand to make a commission or an advisory fee as a result of the move. If an advisor recommends an IRA rollover, ask how it compares with keeping your existing plan or using your new employer’s plan. What services would you receive? What features would you give up? How would the advisor be compensated?
Option 4: Cash out your 401(k) or 403(b)
When you leave your job, you may be able to withdraw some or all of the money in your employer plan rather than roll it over. But cashing out your retirement accounts can have financial consequences. Before requesting a payment, decide how much cash you need and how much you’ll owe in taxes.
Withdrawals of traditional, pretax retirement savings are generally subject to ordinary income tax. Before age 59½, an additional 10% federal early withdrawal tax may apply unless you qualify for an exception. Reaching 59½ generally removes that additional age-based tax, but it doesn’t make pretax withdrawals income-tax-free. Roth savings have different tax rules.
I don’t recall ever recommending that someone cash out an entire retirement account simply because they left a job. If the account owner needs the money for current expenses, I’d first review other available cash, the tax consequences, and how the withdrawal would affect their retirement savings. After all, cashing out a retirement account costs you more than taxes – you’re giving up potential decades of compounding growth.
That said, I’ve done it myself. As a teenager, I worked as a lifeguard at my town pool and accumulated retirement savings without even realizing it. If I recall correctly, when my parents brought the balance to my attention years later, I cashed it out for a whopping $43. A balance built over decades deserves a different level of consideration than my teenage lifeguard earnings.
How to find and review retirement accounts from previous jobs
It’s common for professionals to accumulate several retirement accounts over a career. Vanguard’s How America Retires 2025 research summary cites data covering 22,000 retirement savers in which the median person ages 50 to 59 had three separate workplace retirement accounts. 31% had four or more accounts. Those stats cover workplace accounts, without adding IRAs.
When someone brings me several retirement accounts to review, I usually start with the largest because it often represents the biggest share of their retirement savings. I look at where it’s held, whether they’re still contributing, the investments available, the fees, any outstanding loans, and how the account fits their age and plans for the money. Then I work through the other accounts.
During these reviews, people sometimes discover fees they didn’t know they were paying or investments that no longer fit their goals or comfort with risk. I also check beneficiary designations, which are easy to overlook when someone gets married, has children, or loses a family member. Those changes can leave an old account with instructions that no longer reflect the owner’s wishes.
If you’re reviewing your old retirement accounts on your own, first make a list of your accounts. Review the accounts together, including their investments, costs, and beneficiary designations. That gives you a clearer picture of what you own before deciding whether to consolidate.
If you’ve lost track of an account, start by contacting your former employer. You can also search the Department of Labor’s Retirement Savings Lost and Found database for contact information for plans associated with your work history. A match doesn’t necessarily mean money is still owed to you, so it’s important to contact the plan administrator to confirm whether you have a benefit and how to access it.
What should you do with your 401(k) when you retire?
If you’re retiring, your 401(k) decision may be more focused on whether you’re keeping the account in your former employer’s plan or moving it to an IRA. The Rule of 55 may play an important role in your decision.
Ask the plan administrator whether you can take partial withdrawals or arrange recurring payments, and what restrictions or fees apply. Then consider how those payments would fit with Social Security, cash reserves, and other savings.
At Berkshire Money Management, our Paycheck Replacement Plan coordinates investment withdrawals, Social Security, other retirement income, taxes, cash needs, and spending to show where retirement income may come from month after month. Knowing how you expect to use an account can help you evaluate where to keep it.
Retiring before 59½? Understand the rule of 55
If you retire before 59½, check whether moving your savings would affect your ability to take withdrawals. An exception often called the rule of 55 may allow withdrawals from your employer’s 401(k) or 403(b) without the additional 10% early withdrawal tax if you leave that employer during or after the calendar year you turn 55. Ordinary income taxes can still apply, and the exception does not apply to IRA withdrawals.
Suppose you leave your job at 57 and need some of that employer’s retirement savings for living expenses. Eligible withdrawals from the workplace plan may qualify for the Rule of 55 exception. If you were to roll the entire account into an IRA first, subsequent IRA withdrawals would not qualify under that age-55 exception.
If you leave your job during or after the calendar year you turn 55, be sure to confirm your eligibility and the plan’s withdrawal options before moving money any money you may need before 59½.
How to roll over your 401(k) or 403(b)
If you’re unsure of how a rollover works, you’re not alone. A 2024 U.S. Government Accountability Office report found that about 40% of eligible 401(k) participants didn’t understand the tax consequences of their distribution options. Before requesting a rollover, confirm which accounts need to be opened, what paperwork your old plan requires, and where the payment should be sent.
The rollover process varies by plan. Some require signed paperwork; others handle the request by phone. When I help a client with a rollover, I explain the steps, help with required paperwork, participate in the rollover call when needed, and follow up on progress. At each stage, I explain what needs to happen next.
Request a direct rollover to avoid mandatory tax withholding
With a direct rollover, the payment from your old 401(k) is made to the receiving retirement plan or IRA rather than to you personally. You may still receive a check to forward. What matters is that it’s payable to the receiving plan or IRA, rather than to you.
If a taxable rollover distribution is paid to you personally, the plan generally must withhold 20% for federal income taxes. You typically have 60 days to complete the rollover, and you would need other funds to replace the withheld amount if you wanted to roll over the full distribution. A direct rollover generally avoids these complications.
My recommendation is to have the receiving accounts ready before requesting payment. If your goal is to move both pretax and Roth savings into IRAs while preserving their tax treatment, you generally need a traditional IRA for the pretax savings and a Roth IRA for the Roth savings. Your plan may issue separate payments. Remember that moving pretax savings into a Roth IRA is a conversion that generally creates taxable income.
You should also expect tax paperwork. A direct rollover is generally reported on Form 1099-R even when the transaction doesn’t create taxable income. Make sure to keep the form and rollover records for your tax preparer.
Check your investments after your money is rolled over
Vanguard examined IRA funding activity in 2022 and found that 28% of rollover investors in its sample still had their rollover assets in cash or cash equivalents after 12 months. When your money is sitting outside the market, you’re often losing ground to inflation and missing out on potential growth. Cash may be appropriate for upcoming expenses or part of your investment strategy. The point is to hold it deliberately.
Once your rollover transfer is complete, log in or contact the receiving institution to confirm that the funds arrived and check their investment allocation. Don’t assume your old investments carried over or that the new account automatically invested your money into appropriate funds.
How to decide what to do with your old 401(k)
If you’re considering what to do with an old 401(k), start by gathering your latest account statements, fee information, and plan distribution rules. Confirm your vested balance—the amount you’re entitled to keep—including any employer contributions. Review your beneficiaries and consider when you might need withdrawals.
When I help someone evaluate an old retirement account, I consider how the available choices fit their investments, taxes, and income needs. Then, if moving the money makes sense, I help them work through the process.
If you’re leaving a job or thinking about rolling over accounts from previous employers, I invite you to schedule a 15-minute conversation with Berkshire Money Management. We’d be happy to help you understand your options and talk you through next steps.
A rollover recommendation creates a conflict of interest if the recommending advisor will earn a new fee or increase its current advisory fee on the rolled over assets.
PJ helps professionals and business owners in their 50s and 60s solve the retirement puzzle and move forward with confidence through collaborative, values-based planning. His goal is to help clients see their best-case scenario while preparing for life’s uncertainties.
Goal Tracker
Retire in 5 Years
Keep sight of your progress as you prepare to retire in the next 5 years. Your download includes a printable tracker plus a checklist of 5 signs you’re on the path.







