The Department of Labor’s fiduciary rule looks “iffy” at best, thanks to a March court ruling. The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals says the agency exceeded its authority in insisting that financial services firms act as fiduciaries when giving advice to most tax-deferred savings accounts. However, some financial advisors are ignoring the courts and are going the extra mile for their clients anyway.
Over the last couple of years, I have written several columns on this issue. A “fiduciary” is someone who puts your best interests above his own and that of his company’s. It is a concept that the financial community does not want to see implemented and has gone to great lengths to squash all attempts to do so.
President Barack Obama, recognizing the enormous lobbying power of the financial sector, tried to do an end-run around the financial community, the SEC, and Congress by urging the Department of Labor to implement a fiduciary rule. He almost succeeded, and then came Trump. Although our “populist” president talked a good game during the campaign, he quickly succumbed to the influences of Wall Street and ordered the DOL to “review” its regulation. The rest is history.
However, while brokers and other wealth management advisors, (as well as the annuity and insurance industry) are breathing a collective sigh of relief, one entity, the Certified Financial Planning Board (CFP), is ignoring the decision and going the other way.
The CFP Board, according to its website, is “a non-profit organization acting in the public interest by fostering professional standards in personal financial planning through its setting and enforcement of the education, examination, experience, ethics and other requirements for CFP®certification.” Currently, there are 69,500 members, which represent barely 20% of financial advisors. However, they represent the creme de la crème of CFPs so now you know where to go when shopping for a financial planner.
The CFP Board just announced that starting next year, their members will be required to give advice under a new “best-interest” standard in all aspects of financial advice. I asked Zack Marcotte, a 28-year-old, registered investment advisor, who is sitting for his CFP certification this year, what that means to you, the investor.
“The new rule just makes it that much more important that you look for a Certified Financial Planner when evaluating financial professionals. What this all boils down to is if something is recommended to you, it’s because it’s best for you and not meant to line someone’s pockets.”
Under the old rules, a financial planner was required to act as a fiduciary when he or she was involved in doing a specific financial plan for their clients. However, financial planners can sell their clients a whole shopping list of services from insurance to brokerage services that were not part of their fiduciary duties. And there was the rub.
It is well-known within the industry that for many financial planners, the actual financial plan itself, is a loss-leader. The idea is to get you, the unsuspecting client, in the door, do the plan for a nominal fee, and make the big bucks by selling you annuities, life insurance, or brokerage services. That changes next year.
By raising the bar, all certified financial planners must act in the best interests of their clients when providing all financial advice. That is great news for consumers. The CFP will be required to recommend only using a brokerage product, annuity, or other insurance product, if it is in the best interests of their clients.
I believe that over-time, more and more consumers will seek out only those, like young Zack, who are required by law to act as a fiduciary in all their financial affairs. Hats off to the CFP Board and to all those who have the true interests of their clients at heart.